Welcome to 2698 Old Muskoka Road in Utterson, perfectly positioned between both Bracebridge and Huntsville. This rare offering includes TWO modern homes on over 2.5 acres of private, tree-lined property, set well back from the road for ultimate seclusion. Built in 2019, each dwelling offers completely separate living spaces, an ideal setup for multi-generational families or investors looking for a turn-key rental opportunity. The main homes charming front deck and warm, Muskoka-inspired feel welcome you through an impressive 8' front door. Inside, vaulted ceilings, hardwood floors, and abundant natural light enhance the open-concept kitchen and dining area. The main-floor primary suite features a double closet and a luxurious 5-piece ensuite with his-and-hers sinks. From the dining room, step out to a private back deck overlooking a peaceful backyard with an above-ground pool perfect for summer gatherings. A cozy WETT-certified wood-burning fireplace adds charm to the living room, while a powder room completes the main level. The fully finished lower level offers a second family room, three additional bedrooms, a versatile office or hobby room, and a 4-piece bath. Additional highlights include Lepage windows, an energy-efficient ICF foundation, and a double attached garage with ample storage. The second home currently rents for $2500, is entirely self-sufficient, with its own septic system and propane. Inside, you'll find a custom kitchen, a propane fireplace with shiplap mantle, and a bright, open living area. The spacious upper-level bedroom features a 3-piece bathroom with an oversized tiled shower, while the lower level includes a second bedroom, a workshop or storage space, and a walkout with potential to expand the deck. Whether you're envisioning a family retreat, generating rental income, or simply seeking a private escape, this unique property offers flexibility, and the full Muskoka experience all just minutes from local amenities, with double the appeal!